Indianapolis Colts kicker Spencer Shrader was already having quite the Sunday. He’d nailed both of his extra-point attempts and all four field goals, including two second-half kicks to help the Colts trim their deficit against the Denver Broncos to just two points.
Now, he needed to do it once more for the victory, but this time from 60 yards away with just three seconds on the clock. With the once-raucous home crowd holding its collective breath, Shrader lined up the attempt. Good snap, good hold, solid contact, but the kick drifted right. As Broncos players began to celebrate, the officials convened. Penalty on Denver — illegal leverage, 15-yard penalty. Shrader would have another opportunity, this time from 45 yards out.
>> Subscribe to Sports Spectrum Magazine for more stories where sports and faith connect <<
The second-year kicker out of Notre Dame, in just his sixth NFL game, shook off his miss that didn’t count and calmly booted the ball through the uprights for the wild 29-28 win.
SPENCER SHRADER WINS IT FOR THE @COLTS! pic.twitter.com/LIjazH29Sj
— NFL (@NFL) September 14, 2025
Shrader was then mobbed by teammates, and fans showered him with praise as he exited the field.
“That’s a blessing right there, to see the guys that joyful after a team win like that is truly a special experience,” Shrader told reporters in the locker room after the game. “And to know that I played my part in creating that environment at the end of the day is something that makes you feel really special.”
Then, Shrader revealed he leaned on his assurance of God’s love during the pressure-packed final sequence.
“I was obviously trying to stay as calm as I could on the sideline and just thinking about, ‘Listen, God loves you no matter what,'” he said. “‘Just go out there and do your best for the team. … The Lord has a plan for you.’ He put me in that situation. I believed in Him and I trusted in Him, and I was able to execute. And even if I hadn’t, I know that He would still love me.”
The 26-year-old is a perfect 14-for-14 on field goals in his young career (nine in two games this season) after his five successful attempts on Sunday. He’s also 14-for-14 on extra-point tries. Meanwhile, the Colts are 2-0 for the first time since 2009, and they already have sole possession of first place in the AFC South.
Last season, Shrader bounced around among the New York Jets, Kansas City Chiefs and Colts, both on active rosters and practice squads. After finishing the season on the Chiefs’ injured reserve, he re-signed with the Colts in March. Shrader may have found a long-term home, given his perfect start to the 2025 season.
Before his entrance into the NFL as an undrafted free agent, Shrader spent four seasons with the University of South Florida and his final season of college eligibility with Notre Dame in 2023. He chose Notre Dame in part because of the emphasis on Christian faith at the school.
“My faith is at the forefront of everything that I do,” he said via On SI in December 2022. “… I align with everything that the university represents.”
He continued later: “My No. 1 goal is to impact people in a positive way through my faith, while also contributing to on-the-field success. I know that Notre Dame will be supportive of my goals as a brother in Christ before all else!”
Shrader, who describes himself as a “Follower of Christ” in his Instagram bio, often references his faith in his posts.
View this post on Instagram
View this post on Instagram
This past July, Shrader married former Notre Dame soccer player Korbin Shrader (née Albert), who is currently on the U.S. women’s national team and OL Lyonnes in France. Together, the couple seeks to build a marriage centered on Christ.
View this post on Instagram
Shrader and his Colts will take their undefeated record on the road in Week 3, as they are set to face the Tennessee Titans (0-2) in their first divisional matchup of the season. Kickoff from Nashville is set for Sunday at 1 p.m. ET.
>> Do you know Christ personally? Learn how you can commit your life to Him. <<
RELATED STORIES:
— SS PODCAST: Colts legend, ESPN analyst Jeff Saturday on heart surgery
— NFL top tackler Nick Cross leaning on faith: ‘You just have to trust God’
— Colts punter Rigoberto Sanchez trusts God’s plan, undergoes surgery for tumor
— Colts’ DeForest Buckner baptized: ‘Today I surrendered my whole self to Jesus’
— 15 Christ-following NFL players to watch in 2025

